Monday, October 21, 2013

directing versus filmmaking



On paper,  the proposed remake of “Carrie” is nothing short of fabulous, what with Kimberly Pierce as director, Chloë Grace Moretz and Julianne Moore, as her well-cast stars, and writer Lawrence D. Cohen recruited to update the lean script that he wrote for the Brian DePalma original in 1976.

But, in execution, the completed film is something else, and part of me would like to point to Marvel Comics wunderking Roberto Aquirre-Sacasa, brought in as co-scenarist and to seemingly mess up Cohen's model script, specifically the ending. Seemingly (I hasten to stress). 

Whatever the reason, a mess it is.

While DePalma’s “Carrie” is unusually painterly for a horror film, Pierce’s is blunt and, frankly, crass, qualities in full view in the film’s gross and gratuitous opening sequence – in which Margaret White (Moore) is a frantic, demented bystander to the blood-spurting birth of her own daughter, Carrie.  While Piper Laurie was almost ethereal as the religious-nut mother in the first film, poor Moore is presented as a perspiring, smelly hag. As for the gifted Moretz, she does little else here than walk around with her shoulders squeezed up to her ears.

It’s a hunched performance in more ways than one. Sissy Spacek, twice Moretz's age when she starred in the original, somehow seems years younger - a permamently, fascinatingly stunted child, if you will.

Pierce, whose first two films (1999’s “Boys Don’t Cry” and 2008’s “Stop-Loss”) I admire, may be a case of someone who was prematurely lauded by the critics.  Aside from being hardly prolific, she seems to lack a feel for the camera’s eye.  Pierce inarguably knows a solid story when she sees one and she’s a good director of actors, but she simply isn’t a filmmaker. And that’s what sets her apart from Brian DePalma who is.

And it’s what makes her film so wildly different from – and inferior to – the original.  The new “Carrie” underlines Kimberly Pierce’s few strengths as a director, as well as her major weaknesses as a filmmaker.   

12 comments:

Aleksandar Dragičević said...

Great review!

Ames Productions said...

Spot on review! I was likewise put off by the update. Carrie is displayed more as a mutant with "X-Men" like powers, and less a cauldron of satanic power. After watching this "newer" version, my brother and I (after agreeing it was, otherwise, entertaining) ran home and watched the final 15 minutes of DePalma's flick. Good God. The original "Carrie" is one of the freakiest, weirdest, but also most artsy horror films ever! How is it that a film made in the 70s can be more shocking, gripping and horrific than a film made in 2013?

Kevied said...

Carrie is only viewed as "satanic" by her mother in all versions!

Anonymous said...

Or why you drive by a beat up old trailer with a
Porsche sitting outside? Ralph Lauren polo outlet is is a place the secure good things but be squandered soon be at a cost please money.

But it owns several brands itself, including Ray-Ban, Oakley, Oliver Peoples and REVO.
Crew's Officer's Top Coat, which has button accents and a back belt in order to help create a trim shape.
Cheap Ralph Lauren Sale Uk

Anonymous said...

However, you don't have test away with your floral
prints to make way for geometric routines. Polo Ralph Lauren traded in a variety
yesterday that spanned from a low of $75.35 in order to some high of $77.37.
As a parent, you might be the in order to decide which kind of publicity want cord less mouse with for child.
Try the bloom lace semi opaque tight-end tights in black or frost.

Ralph Lauren Outlet Uk Tracksuit

Anonymous said...

Finding polo Ralph Lauren requires you to decide from various options.
There are a lot of cool brands like D&G, Dior, Prada, Prada Sports, Polo, ralph lauren and tons more.
The cap above is warm and of sufficient length
to cover the whole head. Soon, the polo shirt and tennis shirt
were considered one and exactly the. Faux designer bags
are an exact no, absolutely. Cheap Ralph Lauren Outlet Uk

Anonymous said...

These stores face huge sales in order to allow their shoppers to buy some in their favorite pieces at the lowest price.
So, what's a gentleman or women you should do. 1st, cease throwing away gasoline driving
to your closest Ralph Lauren polo outlet. The the
come you to exploit the greatest resource you can ever hit upon.
It also hosts the annula Chick-fil-a Bowl. Cheap Ralph Lauren Outlet Sale Uk

Anonymous said...

Not only will you hang onto capital an individual will upward turning into additional elegant,
by the way, whenever pull out 1 outfit following fantastic way of training branded specific.
Web has proved to be blessing when it reaches to low price and discounted browsing.
This is a common feeling that arises in everyone's heart.
A number of more the surface of the line, latest fashion can bring.
Cheap Ralph Lauren Outlet Sale Uk

Anonymous said...

It is merely after minute observations you may observe quality of Lauren. Other than, there are so a
great deal of polo objects offered in the marketplace, which are cozy affordable.Do go away much absent from the inadequate high quality
replica your personal. Go shopping for one much more longer style over the bottom of the suit jacket,
but doesn't come using your knees. Cheap Ralph Lauren Polo Uk Kids

Anonymous said...

Now, it also will become one of the parts
of the exciting fashion style by the existence
of the various fashionable styles that use batik. Rugi
dobel khan di ongkir jadinya, maka saran saya perhatikan ukuran, warna
dan bahan untuk mendapatkan jahitan terbaik kaos bola grosir.
bisa rumit kalau duit sudah dikirim walhasil kaos bola idaman yang ditunggu tak
kunjung datang.

My site: sentragrosiran.com/blog/grosiran-mukena-katun-jepang-murah-rp-97000

Anonymous said...

Are cheaper . a collar and buttons and made of a thicker knitted content.
With countless stores to determine from, you're
sure to locate a bargain that's right up your alley.
Just like adults, children are influenced by fashion and be brand conscious at
quite and young age. Children like to keep up with their friends up to adults.
Besides your hold in grass likewise essential. Cheap Ralph Lauren Outlet Uk

Anonymous said...

Physical features include male infertility , consequences of cosmetic surgery or
sexual abuse.

Here is my web-site extenze male enhancement pills side effects