Sunday, March 03, 2019

mr. warner has no regrets

Alicia Malone, a most companionable member of the Turner Classic Movies team, recently hosted a screening of Peter H. Hunt's "1776" during TCM's "31 Days of Oscar" marathon. Turner's pre-screening lead-ins are an entertaining mix of facts, statistics, gossip and Hollywood mythology.

In the case of Hunt's 1972 film, Alicia discussed Jack Warner's "reputation" for recasting the leads of his movie versions of stage productions with more popular film stars. "But, here, he did something unexpected," she explained in her introduction. "He hired much of the Broadway cast, who were all relative unknowns, to reprise their roles for the film."

Then she added, "according to William Daniels, who plays John Adams in the film, Warner apparently had regrets over his casting decision in 'My Fair Lady' where he replaced Julie Andrews with Audrey Hepburn. So, he wasn't about to make the same mistake again." It's the last sentence that jumped out at me... He wasn't about to make the same mistake again.

I have no idea if the sentiment in that sentence is fact or if it's an opinion (either Daniels' or Alicia's) but, given that "My Fair Lady" would turn out to be the highest-grossing film made at Warner Bros. in the 1960s - as well as the highest-grossing Warner film up to that point and the highest-grossing film with Jack Warner's name on it (he personally produced it) - it's highly unlikely that the studio head/mogul would have any regrets at all or thought that he made any mistake.

And a major reason for the film's box-office success? Two words: Audrey Hepburn. It's doubtful that Hepburn's co-star, Rex Harrison, was a much of a draw. Harrison - a terrific actor who, of course, starred in the stage version of "My Fair Lady" and won a well-deserved Oscar for his amazingly soulful performance in the film - was frankly never a box-office attraction or even an A-list star. True, there was the allure of the moviegoing public getting to see one of Broadway's greatest musicals on screen, but one can safely bet the rent money that Audrey Hepburn was the main attraction.

And it's unlikely that Jack Warner had any regrets when the critical acclaim came in or when the film was nominated for twelve Academy Awards.

On the other hand, "1776" with its cast of unknowns, was only "moderately successful," as Alicia pointed out in her intro. Gosh, I wonder why.

To be fair, "1776" is an excellent film musical but it was made at a time when there was virtually no interest among either critics or moviegoers in musicals. Also, the piece really doesn't lend itself to "star casting." It's an ensemble production, with roles that call for character actors. So Warner's decision to go with the Broadway cast was a no-brainer. It made sense.

Ever underrated, "1776" received only one Oscar nomination. Harry Stradling, Jr. was nominated for Best Cinematography.

With that clarified, a few more relevant notes...

Jack L. Warner: Getting back to Warner's so-called "reputation" for recasting the leads of his movie versions of stage productions with more popular film stars, that's not entirely true. His studio produced two back-to-back musicals in the 1950s, both co-directed by Stanley Donen and George Abbott and both with casts recruited from their stage productions. But both were also anchored by one major film star - Doris Day in "The Pajama Game" (1957) and Tab Hunter in "Damn Yankees" (1958).

(click on poster to enlarge) 

It's important to note that, when it came to filming stage musicals, Jack Warner's dictum was not to tamper with the source material (the way MGM often did with its Broadway acquisitions).

In 1962, his studio released two major screen musicals. "The Music Man," with Robert Preston, the lead in the original Broadway version, and "Gypsy," for which Warner made an exception and went with stars - Rosalind Russell, Natalie Wood and Karl Malden. Jack Warner may not have had any regrets about any decisions that he made but he surely regretted the negative media response to any perceived "mistakes."

The last film he personally produced for Warner Bros., before becoming an independent producer, was "Camelot" (1967), another musical with two movie stars (albeit eclectic ones) as the leads - Vanessa Redgrave and Richard Harris. This time out, Julie Andrews, again star of the stage version (opposite Richard Burton), was replaced by Redgrave.

As an independent, Warner produced only two films, both for Columbia Pictures - "Dirty Little Billy," an odd little Western starring Michael J. Pollard, and the aforementioned "1776." Warner purchased the screen rights to the musical - $1.25 million - with his own money. And although Warner went with most of the Broadway cast, during the press interviews for the film, he admitted that he had no idea who his actors were and had no interaction with them during the filming. For the record, the non-Broadway additions to the film were Blythe Danner who replaced Betty Buckley as Martha Jefferson, Donald Madden as John Dickinson and Stephen Nathan as a courier who sings the haunting "Mama Look Sharp."

"1776": Filmed as a roadshow presentation with intermission, it was edited down to 141 minutes for its release with the song, "Cool Considerate Men" excised, cut at the suggestion of Richard M. Nixon, who was a Warner friend.  In 1992, the film was restored by Joseph Caporiccio to 180 minutes for its LaserDisc release, which includes the intermission break and "Cool Considerate Men," as well as an overture, a different titles sequence and exit music. Forty minutes of other bits were reinstated. For some reason, the film's DVD version runs a shorter 166 minutes.

William Daniels: One of the busiest and most productive character actors, Daniels has had only one lead on screen - in "1776" - although he is noted for memorable supporting turns in "The Graduate," opposite Elizabeth Wilson as the parents of Dustin Hoffman's Benjamin, and "A Thousand Clowns." And, of course, there's the David Hasselhoff TV series, "Knight Rider," which employed only his voice, making use of his trademark elocution. Oh, yes, and he would appear with someone named - let's see -  Audrey Hepburn in "Two of the Road," Stanley Donen's 1967 sophisticated romance in which Daniels and Eleanor Bron play the unctuous Howard and Cathy Manchester to the hilt.

Hepburn versus Andrews: Although it hasn't been widely reported, the reason that Audrey Hepburn eventually signed on to do "My Fair Lady" is that Jack Warner wore her down with countless offers involving money, until it was difficult to refuse. Throughout the 1960s, Elizabeth Taylor was touted as Hollywood's highest-paid actress because of the $1 million she received for "Cleopatra." But that distinction actually belongs to Hepburn, who never publicized it. As early as 1956, she received $750,000 for "War and Peace," then the highest salary for any actor or actress at that time.

Hepburn had also starred in a Warner film which had been the studio's highest grossing movie of the 1950s - the 1959 release, "The Nun's Story." A serious movie about religion was an audience hit? Jack Warner surely must have figured that, if Audrey Hepburn can attract moviegoers to a film like "The Nun's Story," she can draw people to anything.

Jack Warner's final offer to Hepburn was $1.25 million, with options for profit participation if the film was a hit. It's the same deal that Marlon Brando had on "Mutiny on the Bounty." The difference: "My Fair Lady" was indeed a financial hit. "Cleopatra" and "Mutiny on the Bounty" weren't, leaving no major profits upon the films' releases. Also, unlike those two titles, the filming of "My Fair Lady" was an exercise in professionalism, made on time and on budget with no star outbursts or misbehavior.

The film rights to "My Fair Lady" were owned by CBS and controlled by its chairman, Bill Paley, who sold the rights to Warner for a then-record $5.5 million. The movie had a huge budget and was eventually made for a whopping $17 million. That's why Warner thought his film needed a star.

Julie Andrews was only 22 when she starred in the stage production of "My Fair Lady" in 1956 and was untested in terms of film. There were doubts whether she could carry a film, any film, or if she was photogenic enough. So Hepburn got the role. But even if she evaded Warner's endless courting and turned it down, it was unlikely that Julie Andrews would have been hired. Shirley Jones was reportedly on Warner's list as the next-in-line.

Sing out, Audrey! When Hepburn signed to do "My Fair Lady," it was with the clear understanding that she would do her own singing, which she previously did on screen in "Funny Face" and "Breakfast at Tiffany's." She does a killer rendition of George and Ira Gershwin's "How Long Has This Been Going On?" in "Funny Face."

The fact is, Hepburn recorded all her songs for "My Fair Lady." (I have an old audio cassette of all her tracks.) Her voice is fine but clearly not operatic. So the usual suspect, Marni Nixon, was brought in to replace Hepburn's singing voice on about 90 percent of the songs. Which brings me to my one reservation about "My Fair Lady," both the stage and screen versions.

It never made sense to me that a guttersnipe like Eliza Doolittle who speaks in a rough Cockney accent would open her mouth to sing and, suddenly, a beautiful, lilting soprano comes out of it. (I have the same problem with Bloody Mary's singing voice in the film version of "South Pacific.") I have to ask: What were Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe thinking when they sat down to write songs for the character? Shouldn't Eliza's singing voice be more aligned to her bedraggled personality - and, more to the point, to Hepburn's husky voice? Audrey Hepburn had a really distinctive speaking voice, which is what makes Nixon's trilling in the songs seem so ridiculous. Come on, these are obviously two different voices.

It's interesting that for Rex Harrison, a non-singer, the composers wrote songs that he could talk his way through, rather than sing. Just compare Harrison on the original cast album "My Fair Lady" with Harrison on the film's soundtrack album. He actually attempted to "sing" in the play. But by the time he made the film, he was talking his way through most of his songs. Warner originally wanted Cary Grant to play Henry Higgins, an apt choice in my book, given that Grant could actually sing: He started out doing musicals in regional theaters both here and in Great Britain.

Julie survives! Andrews immediately became something of a cause célèbre for Hollywood, which rallied around her after mean old Jack Warner mistreated her. In a virtual whirlwind, Walt Disney offered her "Mary Poppins," she made "The Americanization of Emily" and became an icon overnight with "The Sound of Music," all within two years. The year that "My Fair Lady" won the Oscar as Best Picture, Andrews took home the Best Actress award for "Mary Poppins." When Harrison was handed his Oscar for "My Fair Lady," he diplomatically thanked "both my fair ladies" and kissed Audrey who had presented him with his award.

Alan Jay Lerner: Unlike most of his Broadway peers (with the obvious exception being Neil Simon), Lerner enjoyed something of a privileged relationship with Hollywood. It has never been noted but, when one of his stage works was made into a film, Lerner himself adapted the material for the screen: "Brigadoon," "Paint Your Wagon," "My Fair Lady," "Camelot" and "On a Clear Day You Can See Forever." He also had a hand in the assorted TV adaptations of his work. In the case of "Gigi," it was the other way around: First, he wrote the screenplay for the 1958 Vincente Minnelli film and then adapted it for the stage in 1973.

More Rex! Turner Classic Movies will devote its daytime schedule on Tuesday, March 5 exclusively to Harrison (who, in his day, was nicknamed Sexy Rexy), starting at 6 a.m. (est.) with "Over the Moon" (1940), costarring Merle Oberon, followed by a 7:30 a.m. screening of Vincente Minnelli's "The Reluctant Debutante" (1958), which Harrison made with his wife (at the time), the fabulous Kay Kendall, shortly after his "My Fair Lady" run on Broadway. Also: David Lean's "Blithe Spirit" (1945), "King Richard and the Crusaders" (1954, "The Yellow Rolls-Royce" (1964) and Sir Carol Reed's excellent "Night Train to Munich (1940). The day is topped off with - what else? - "My Fair Lady" at 5 p.m. (est.).

Another Eliza: Laura Benanti is currently playing the iconic role in the new Lincoln Center revival of "My Fair Lady" and, not surprisingly, she's exceptional. While Benanti has said that she grew up listening to the original cast album and idolizing Julie Andrews, the Benanti performance that I saw owes a lot to Hepburn's interpretation, more than to Andrews'.

Or maybe I'm projecting.


Regarding Comments: All comments are enthusiastically appreciated but are moderated before publication. Replies signed "unknown" or "anonymous" are not encouraged. Please sign any response with a name (real or fabricated) or initials.  Be advised that a "name" will be assigned to any accepted post signed "unknown" or "anonymous." Thank you.

~images~
(from top) 

~Rex Harrison and Audrey Hepburn making it all legal with Jack Warner prior to the filming of "My Fair Lady"
~photography: Warner Bros.1963©

~Alicia Malone, TCM host
~photography: Turner Classic Movies 2018©

~Hepburn and Harrison between scenes on the "My Fair Lady" set
~photography: Warner Bros. 1963©

 ~Poster art for "The Pajama Game" 
~Warner Bros. 1957©

~Eleanor Bron, William Daniels and Cathy Jones in "Two for the Road" 
~photography: Twentieth Century-Fox 1967©

~Hepburn with Julie Andrews at the 1965 Oscarcast
~photography: The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences 1965©

 ~Hepburn and Fred Astaire in "Funny Face"
~photography: Paramount Pictures 1957©

 ~Laura Benanti as Eliza Doolittle in the latest revival of "My Fair Lady"
~photography: Joan Marcus/Lincoln Center 2019©

25 comments:

mike schlesinger said...

I think J.L.'s regrets were that he felt he hurt Andrews by skipping over her. But as history has shown, it worked out well for everyone. (Though he still has to answer for not persuading Karloff to do the film version of ARSENIC AND OLD LACE.)

As for 1776: The laaerdisc was "everything," including some stuff Hunt would rather not have been put back, including, I believe, an overture that was never in the film. He personally edited it to the 166" version on DVD, but has since regretted THAT because he dropped the reprise of "The Lees of Old Virginia." As he put it, "I've gotten a ton of shit over that, and I now realize I shouldn't have done it." So there may well be a fourth version down the line.

joe baltake said...

Mike- When it comes to "1776," more is not enough for me. I love all the stuff on the laserdisc and recently had a DVD copy made from it. It's a wonderful film, one those rare movies that seems to get better with each viewing. Peter H. Hunt should have had more of a Hollywood career. -J

Joan said...

I recently discovered the Broadway channel on Sirius radio and was just treated to William Daniels singing “Sit Down, John” and Rex Harrison talking his way through, “I’ve Grown Accustomed to her Face.” It made this incredibly rich post even more enjoyable.
thanks, Joe

Pamela West said...

Reading about "Sit Down, John" makes at least 3 references to other Broadway shows in "Hamilton." There's also George Washington singing a line that he's the very model of the modern major general from Pirates of Penzance, and Aaron Burr singing the line "you've got to be carefully taught" from South Pacific. Wonder how many more there are in the score?

Alex said...

Yeah, it's kind of naieve to believe that Jack Warner "made a mistake" when his casting decision resulted in a critically acclaimed, Oscar-nominated and high-grossing film. Some mistake!

Bunuel said...

I think it's hilarious that Warner didn't know - or care to know - any of the actors he hired for "1776."

Charlotte said...

You've read my mind, Joe. The type of songs that Lerner and Loewe wrote of Eliza make little sense to me, too. Not only does the character suddenly have an operatic voice, but when she sings, she also has perfect elocution! If Henry Higgins heard her sing "I Could Have Danced All Night," he would have had no qualms about taking her to Ascot or to the ball.

Daryl Chin said...

Rex Harrison's career actually was a lot more complicated than simply being characterized as a non-a-list star (which isn't true). Harrison had acquired a reputation in England as a prime stage comedian, in plays by Shaw and Noel Coward (among others). MAJOR BARBARA and BLITHE SPIRIT were two British films which were major successes in the US, which prompted US studios to offer contracts. Harrison accepted 20th Century Fox's offer because he was assured that he would be given star treatment, and, once in the US, he starred in ANNA AND THE KING OF SIAM (Fox's most expensive film of 1946, and a big hit) and THE GHOST AND MRS. MUIR (also a big hit). On THE GHOST AND MRS. MUIR, he formed a close friendship with Joseph L. Mankiewicz, which resulted in the 1947 ESCAPE (a good film made in England, though it is a very difficult film to see now)... but Harrison's career was derailed (spectacularly) by the suicide of Carole Landis (they had an affair, and he had dinner with her the night she died). Lilli Palmer's decision to stick by him meant that Palmer's career was also affected; they would do several Broadway plays, as well as plays in England. (Two plays were THE FOURPOSTER and BELL, BOOK AND CANDLE.) The success of MY FAIR LADY brought Harrison back to his previous status (though old dogs can't learn new tricks; during the run of MY FAIR LADY, Harrison met and started an affair with Kay Kendall; learning that she had been diagnosed with leukemia, he went to Lilli Palmer and asked for a divorce, and married Kendall). But he had been an A-list star for 20th Century Fox, and he also took some interesting chances, such as Preston Sturges' UNFAITHFULLY YOURS.

Cary Grant's comment on the offer of MY FAIR LADY was, How could I play Henry Higgins, when the way I talk is closer to the cockney of Eliza Dolittle?

joe baltake said...

Thanks again, Daryl, for the wealth of information. My reference to Rex Harrison not being an A-list star (or box-office draw) stems from a facile comparison: Sizing him up alongside other British actors (and his peers at the time), such as Cary Grant, James Mason and David Niven. I appreciate that Harrison was a major actor who made some successful films, but I always assumed that Hollywood did not see him in the same light as Grant, Mason and Niven, that he wasn't as "important" as they were. One should never assume, right? It never occurred to me to speculate where his American film career might have gone if not for the Landis scandal. The stage version of "My Fair Lady" certainly revived his career, taking him back to Hollywood for "Cleopatra," "Midnight Lace" and the movie of "Lady." But am I incorrect thinking that, despite fine work in all those films (and his Oscar win), he wasn't considered a major player at that particular time? -J

mike schlesinger said...

IIRC, Grant told Warner that not only would he not play Higgins, but if anyone other than Harrison were cast, he wouldn't even SEE it!

joe baltake said...

Mike- You do recall correctly, although I personally always speculated about the veracity of that off-quoted quote. I've read it applied also to "The Music Man" when Warner offered Grant the role of Harold Hill - again, that Grant wouldn't even bother to see it if Robert Preston wasn't in it. Both sound like they were made up by some flak. On the other hand, I have read Grant quoted in interviews that he told Warner that he would be inappropriate as Henry Higgins because, like Eliza, he had a Cockney accent. However, from where I sit, towards the end of his career, Grant didn't sound Cockney at all, just British. I would have loved to see him in the role. -J

mike schlesinger said...

Could be, but Cary was quite a wit. Anyway, he would have been all wrong for MFL. Higgins is supposed to be a bastard--you could argue that Harrison was essentially playing himself--but Cary is just too gosh-darn lovable, and he would have given Higgins a sympathy that he absolutely did not warrant. OTOH, that charm would have been perfect for Harold Hill, though as he noted, Preston owned the role and J.L. made the right call by retaining him. BTW, some years ago Craig Bierko starred in a Broadway revival of TMM, and he did the most jaw-dropping impression of Preston I've ever heard. I found if I squinted a little, I could pretend it really was Bob up there.

joe baltake said...

Mike- It never occurred to me that Cary Grant would have been too nice to play Higgins, but you're right. Also, Higgins is definitely closer to Harrison's reputed off-screen personality. BTW, my wife and I saw Craig Bierko in that revival of "The Music Man," a great production of the show - and, yes, Bierko was excellent, very reminiscent of Preston. If my memory serves me correctly, it was a rainbow production: A black actress played the mayor's wife, Eulalie Mackechnie Shinn. I liked that the entire cast played trombones for the finale. -J

Sheila said...

"Patter Songs - I believe that's what Lerner and Loewe called the songs that they wrote for Harrison in "My Fair Lady."

joe baltake said...

Thanks, Sheila! Yes, "Patter Songs" - I recall that expression.

Lisa Delman said...

We know from recent events that Hollywood denizens are far from loyal, so it's no surprise that Audrey Hepburn was demonized for accepting the role in "My Fair Lady."

thomas whittaker said...

To these people who complain about Hepburn accepting the role, instead of turning it down, I ask: Would any of them turn down a job so someone else can be hired?

Bob Lindstrom said...

One interesting aspect of Warner's production of "The Music Man" is that they not only imported the original Broadway director, Morton DaCosta, to direct the film; more remarkably, they brought the original Broadway dance corps to Hollywood for the shoot!

joe baltake said...

Thanks, Bob. I had no idea that Morton DeCosta brought his dance troupe from the Broadway production to perform in the film. I've always appreciated that DaCosta actually had his film's character actors - such as Mary Wicks, William Faucett an number, rather than have it performed by the usual unseen chorus. -J

Billy from Philly said...

I was always amazed that Hollywood at large decided to stand behind Julie Andrews and not Audrey Hepburn during the "My Fair Lady" flap.

Billy from Philly said...

I was always amazed that Hollywood at large decided to stand behind Julie Andrews and not Audrey Hepburn during the "My Fair Lady" flap

Rene said...

Replying to Billy... I have one word: Typical. Typical behavior by Lalaland!

Caitlin said...

I could not resist commenting. Perfectly written!

Andrew K. said...

Thanks for this marvelous post! I seriously enjoyed reading it.

joe baltake said...

Thank you, Caitlin & Andrew! -J