Everyone
routinely mistakes George Seaton's "Miracle on 34th St." (1947),
featuring a young Natalie Wood and John Payne (above) and Edmund Gwenn
(below), for a Christmas movie.
Nope.
It's actually a Thanksgiving movie. Well, almost.
Thursday, November 26, 2015
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
So true!
Good point, Joe, but the film actually covers both holidays. Still, Thanksgiving movies are rare and it would be nice to include this one among them.
I agree with Brian, the film traverses two holidays. That said, I think the TV stations that air "Miracle" every year should start showing it on Thanksgiving day and not wait until Christmas.
I watch this every year with my family on Thanksgiving. I couldn't be with them this year, so we had a quote-off. My mom would text me a favorite line from the movie and I would text her back the next big one. Aka I've seen this film way too many times!
Miracle on 34th Street is, as your fans confirm, a holiday season movie, not a strictly Christmas movie. Of course, the entire premise of the movie questions — and sweetly answers — the actuality of Santa Claus. It has been part of my life for so many years, I cannot remember when I first saw it. But it is the primary reason I bought a VCR when they came on the market, long before DVRing. “Miracle” was often scheduled to air at an ungodly hour or at a time when it was impossible to see so I bought it in VHS and still screen it every year.
As essential as “Miracle” is, it is not the first Christmas season movie I was. That honor belongs to another Christmas season spanning movie, an oldie and my wittiest and sweetest favorite: The Man Who Came to Dinner. As you noted, though, I screen them close to Thanksgiving. Both movies are essential to properly begin my parade of Christmas favorites, which I own and watch (in VHS) in this order, typically.
Christmas in Connecticut
A Christmas Story
The Santa Clause
Holiday Affair
Holiday Inn
The Holiday - obviously a recent addition
A Christmas Carol - the Alistair Sims version
The Bishop’s Wife - Loretta Young, Cary Grant, David Niven (and another charmer with Monty Wooley)
White Christmas - usually the concluding movie because of its sentimentality, memories of my father, and the song White Christmas.
Two other films are in my library and sometimes I watch them, but not always: Elf and It’s a Wonderful Life. Will Ferrell is cute in Elf, but I have to be in the mood for his brand of zaniness. Bob Newhart’s wonderfully dry, droll appearance helps a lot. Then there’s IAWL. Frank Capra’s saccharin opus is iconic yet I can’t say it genuinely entertains me. Mostly watch this one, if I do, because of some need to check off a mental list of Christmas films, staying on the Nice list, I suppose.
Post a Comment